Telefonica O2 and e-Plus merger: a new 4th network operator makes little sense

Today the FT reported that in order to overcome objections to the proposed take-over of E-Plus “Telefónica has offered to equip a new German mobile competitor with spectrum”.  This is similar to the offer by Hutchinson 3 in the context of its take-over of Orange Austria. In the event there was of course no new network based entrant in Austria, the aim of the Telefonica O2 and E-Plus tie up is to take costs out of the industry by reducing the number of mobile network operators. At this stage of the industry life cycle consolidation at network level is expected. This is driven by high prices paid for spectrum and continuing high LTE capex while revenues remain flat or in decline. When free cash flow declines, capital has to be taken out of the industry simply to get back to returns that are not below the cost of capital.

The FT also reports that Telefónica promised concessions for MVNOs. Competition remedies at wholesale level in the form of a reference wholesale access price offer – similar to what was agreed to by Hutchison in Austria – are a much more effective remedy. This is particularly true for Germany which already has a vibrant MVNO market. Indeed E-Plus pioneered the multi-band MVNO strategy and hence concessions at wholesale level are likely to be impactful. Given the competitive MVNO market in Germany, regulating wholesale prices provides an effective insurance against retail price increases, which might otherwise result from the tie-up.

If indeed wholesale price regulation ends up as the key remedy, and this in Europe’s largest mobile market, we are one step closer to the structural separation of the European mobile industry into NetCos and ServiceCos.

Written by Stefan Zehle, CEO, Coleago Consulting

What conditions will be attached to O2 Germany’s acquisition of E-Plus?

In my blog post on Monday the 29^th of July “EU in a muddle over roaming rules”, I pointed to the conditions imposed on H3G Austria to allow its acquisition of Orange Austria (Case M.6497 “Hutchison 3G Austria Holdings GmbH / Orange Austria Telecommunications GmbH), notably to publish a Reference Wholesale Access Offer for MVNOs with a data price of €0.002 per Mbyte.

The pending acquisition of E-Plus Germany by Telefonica O2 Germany will also require approval by the European Commission. It is unlikely that that it can be argued that the mobile market in Germany is more competitive than that in Austria. In fact there are indications that it is less competitive and the acquisition would leave Germany with only three Mobile Network Operators.  If therefore the Commission imposes the same or similar conditions on the E-Plus / Telefonica O2 Germany deal, we will see a Reference Wholesale Access Offer, also with a per Mbyte rate of €0.002 per Mbyte, in Germany which is the EU’s biggest mobile market.

Effectively the conditions imposed in the context of industry consolidation may eventually lead to EU-wide mandated wholesale prices.  This is a backdoor way of starting to regulate the European mobile industry and effectively create a regulatory difference between mobile access providers (MNOs) and mobile retailers (MVNOs). What may follow is an Accounting Separation requirement being imposed on EU mobile network operators.

Written by Stefan Zehle, CEO, Coleago